Monday, August 29, 2011

When Friends and Family Read Your Book...Or Don't

After my debut novel came out in May, I had the interesting experience of discovering who read my novel and who didn't, among my circle of friends, acquaintances, and family.

Now, in my view, no one is required to read my novel, either for blood or friendship, but I did want to share the observations I've made, because other writers may go through the same thing sooner or later.

Some wonderful older women at my church made a point of buying my book immediately and then recommending it to their friends. One of our male elders did the same thing.

But there were also a few strange silences mixed in--a couple of close relatives who have not read it or even said a word about it, a few acquaintances who would be *exactly* the people I would expect to read it, but did not.

Who did I expect NOT to read my novel, even among my close friends and family?


Those who don't like reading, have trouble reading, or have a strong antipathy to romance.

Even though my novel includes a lot of action and suspense, readers don't know that before they begin the novel. It's only natural for a lot of men to assume that because it's a romance, it will not be to their taste. The men who have read it have enjoyed it, but it takes a strong man to make it past the beautiful, feminine cover. :-)

I have a very dear friend who is dyslexic and struggles to read. I know that if my novels ever come out on audiobook, she will be first in line, but reading a 400-page printed novel would be torture for her.

Who did I expect would read it, among my circle of friends?

Those who like to read--women who were English majors in college, people I've known for years who like ideas and books.

Three things to remember when your book comes out and you encounter the surprises of readership among your friends and family:

1) Non-writers do not understand the effort an author puts into writing, or how personal the publication of a book can be. To me, this novel may be a dream, but to a non-writer, it's just another book. Make an effort to see from that perspective--most friends honestly don't know how much it means to have someone you know read your novel.

2) Some of your acquaintances already may have had the experience of reading a friend's book, whether fiction or nonfiction, traditionally-published or self-published. If they did not care for that book, they may feel awkward and reluctant to read another one they may not like. This may become even more common as self-publishing soars to new heights. Though there are some excellent self-published books, many of them suffer from a lack of professional editing. Your circle of friends may get book fatigue from feeling they are expected to read the books of every author they know.

3) Resist the temptation to speculate. For the most part, friends and family who don't read your novel simply aren't interested, for reasons usually unrelated to you. It is much better to focus on all the friends who read it and support you, the unexpected moments of affirmation when a telephone call comes out of the blue.

Here's one of those moments. This weekend, a friend of mine left a message on my answering machine after finishing the novel--a long, heartfelt message. The phrase I will treasure: "Your novel is full of God's love."

When I have such uplifting and positive things to keep in mind, it helps me avoid the trap of taking it personally if a friend doesn't show interest.

Have you ever been pleasantly surprised by a friend's reaction to your writing?

16 comments:

Suze said...

'Resist the temptation to speculate.'

In a nutshell, quite perfect counsel, methinks.

Sarah Forgrave said...

I'll admit...This part scares me about getting published someday. Thanks for the reminder to not take it personally. :)

Katie Ganshert said...

Oh my - I didn't even think about this!! This was so good for me to read, because I think I was one of those crazies who honestly thought everybody close to me would read my book. I'm sure when that ended up not happening, I'd do ALL kinds of speculating! Thanks for the advice, Rosslyn!

OurCrazyFarm said...

I have enjoyed your blog immensely the past few days, and have appreciated your experiences as a new author. I am in the process of completing my first book and relate to so much of what you share. Thanks for taking the lead and walking us "newbies" through this book publishing process with you!

Loree Huebner said...

Nice post.

I recently had a ten page history article published. I sent a copy of the magazine to my brother. He called me on the phone and kept saying, "You're article is so good." He said it over and over. I tried to change the subject but he kept coming back to it. I think when I told him about getting an article published, he thought more on the lines of a small newspaper article or something. He was surprised.

I cried when I got off the phone.


I didn't think the article would interest many people at my place of work. After showing the magazine, I had a 2 requests from people at work for a copy. One I didn't even know he was a history buff, and the other - who I hardly have any contact with - he wanted a copy for his wife. She is a history teacher and a big Civil War buff to boot.

Made me feel pretty good.

TC Avey said...

Thanks for sharing, I have already experienced some of this with my blog. It has been surprising the family and friends that have not even logged onto my blog. while there were a few I did not expect would, since they are not into blogging, there have been others that have shocked me by their lack of support. oh well, it's good practice for when my book does get published (wink wink).

Caroline Starr Rose said...

Your "resist the temptation to speculate" makes me think of fellow middle-grade author Irene Latham's "err on the side of love" -- something I need to do more often.

Rosslyn Elliott said...

Suze - you have a genius for extracting the nut. :-)

Sarah - The people who really matter to you will read it.

Katie - I want you to report back to me about whether any of your friends and family did not.

OurCrazyFarm - I looked to see if you had a blog to follow...I didn't see one in the Blogger profile, but I would love to follow if I can. Thanks for your kind words!

Loree, what a great story! It really does mean so much when a family member responds in a sincere and positive way to one's work.

TC Avey - I had the same experience when I was first blogging, and keeping a more family-oriented, journal-type blog. I couldn't believe that some family members didn't ever read it, but you're right, the same principle applies. Of course you and I would probably be regular readers of any family member's blog, but that's because we're writers. :-)

Caroline - I'm going to look up Irene Latham now. I'm woefully undereducated in YA. You can be my link to what I should be reading--besides MAY B., of course. That's a given.

Lorena said...

I was very surprised when my husband finally read my first novel and liked it (at least he said so, ha!) I didn't think he would like it since, as you know, the most important characters are women. During my last trip to Ecuador, my sister and niece said they wanted to read my stuff. I never considered sharing with them since I write in English (though both of them speak it. But I just didn't think of asking.) I'm certain that if I ever get published my parents won't read the book because:
1. They don't like to read fiction (all they read is the newspaper :))
2. They don't read in English.
In a way, it's a relief...

Susan J. Reinhardt said...

Hi Rosslyn -

Great topic!

Several people have said they loved my writing or something ministered to them. Those comments help me press on when this journey gets tiring.

Blessings,
Susan :)

Alena Belleque said...

As someone who regularly reviews books on her personal blog, I've encountered this from a slightly different perspective. Some of my most dedicated blog readers (and commenters) are people who I either never though read blogs, or whom I do not know personally and yet they are very invested in my life. On the flip side, some of the people who encouraged (read, in some cases, "bullied") into writing a blog in the first place now never comment, unless it is to let me know that they don't plan to comment or that they don't read my blog (um, what?). It's been a bit strange and at times unpleasant. But those women who read my blog faithfully, and take time to leave encouragement or their thoughts? Priceless! :)

Stacy Henrie said...

Great post! I don't typically share my manuscripts with any family but my DH. So it'll be interesting to see which ones do read my books some day.

I left you an award on my blog. It's for bloggers with 200 or less followers. If you already have that number, just take it as a way to say I enjoy your blog. :)

Donna K. Weaver said...

Wandered over her from Stacy's blog. I love this post! I've discovered the truths of this post even just from my beta friends. It's almost best to have strangers read than friends. It's too hard for those who read to separate you out of the book and give you a fair assessment.

Rosslyn Elliott said...

Lorena - I'm glad some of your family shows interest! And they should--the novels are great. :-)

Susan - That support really can be a lifesaver sometimes. I've experienced that lately.

Alena - What? That is even more bizarre than usual for blogland! I do understand what you're saying, though, because I experienced the same thing to a lesser degree with my personal blog. It has made me really appreciate those generous women you mention. Now what gets weird is the issue of reviews. This whole time, ever since Fairer came out, I've been following a policy of trying not to comment on reviews, not even to leave my thanks. Some people on a major writer's loop said it was unprofessional. But I'm starting to think that may be changing. The internet is so dialogue-oriented that I've seen more interaction between authors and readers.

Rosslyn Elliott said...

Stacy, thank you so much! I do in fact have more than 200 followers (my widget is broken and won't show the count) but I still love the award and the encouragement.

Donna - Thanks for coming by from Stacy's blog. On beta readers: I'm blessed with some really good ones who are also friends, but I agree, strangers can sometimes be more objective.

Margo Berendsen said...

Those are really good observations - I wouldn't have thought of them right off. In some cases, I would also allow for the reality of "mood" - being in the mood for a certain type of novel, being in the mood to read at all - even big time readers sometimes have no-read moods.